Miners Fined – Fatal Pony Accident at Denaby Main Colliery

Mexborough & Swinton Times – Friday 10 August 1894

Denaby Miners Fined – Fatal Pony Accident at Denaby Main Colliery

James Massie and Joseph Hughes, miners employed at Denaby Main Colliery, were charged with breaches of Special Rule No. 4 and Special Rule No. 106 following an accident on 25 June.

Mr. Hickmott prosecuted on behalf of the colliery company, while Mr. William Gichard represented the defendants.

The charges arose from an accident in a drift at Denaby Main Colliery, where a fall of roof had occurred and the men had been employed removing debris.

Henry Cooke, a deputy, instructed the men to take loaded corves down the incline and return empty ones using a pony. He specifically ordered them to keep the pony behind the loaded corve, never in front of it.

Cooke remained with the men for nearly an hour and observed them obeying these instructions. Before leaving to make his rounds, he repeated the warning.

After his departure, another worker, William Bramley, was asked to take the pony down the incline ahead of the loaded corve.

Bramley reached the bottom safely, but a descending tub subsequently struck the pony, killing it. Bramley was also knocked down, suffering several broken ribs and an injury to his spine.

He was hospitalised for approximately a month.

The defendants explained that the pony had been reluctant to follow the corve and that difficulties had arisen because the load was unusually heavy and water in the drift had caused Hughes to slip and lose control.

Mr. Gichard argued that the deputy’s instructions had been obeyed in spirit, if not literally, and that the accident had resulted from several unusual circumstances.

The Chairman disagreed, stating that the instructions had been explicit and were intended to prevent precisely such an accident.

Although the magistrates did not consider the defendants’ actions wilful, they held that the men had disobeyed their instructions and contributed to the serious injuries suffered by a fellow worker.

Each defendant was fined 20s., including costs.