Child Mother’s Alleged Crime – Girl Committed for Trial – Terrible Story

April 1914

Mexborough & Swinton Times – Saturday 4 April 1914

Child Mother’s Alleged Crime

Conisboro’ Girl Committed for Trial

A Terrible Story

At the Doncaster West Riding Police Court on Monday, before Mr. J. W. Hodgson and Mr. F. W. Cocking, Minnie Scott, the fifteen-year-old Conisboro’ girl, who was charged with the wilful murder of her newly-born child, was committed to take her trial at the next Leeds Assizes.

In accordance with the provisions of the Children’s Act, the Court was cleared of all except those immediately interested in the proceedings.

Minnie Scott was present in court, but appeared to take little evidence in the proceedings, although when her mother was in the box it was observed that she was weeping.

Mr. G. C. Peever, for the Director of Public Prosecutions, prosecuted, and Mr. J. A. Baddiley appeared for the girl, whilst Inspector Lloyd watched the case on behalf of the N.S.P.C.C.

Case for the Prosecution

Mr. G. C. Peever said the girl, Minnie Scott, was 15 years of age. Some two months before Christmas it came to the knowledge of her mother, with whom she was living, that she was in a certain condition. The mother and the girl’s sister, who was living next-door, apparently made not the slightest preparation for the girl’s confinement. After the 27th of February, apparently the mother’s interest in what had happened entirely vanished, and it might well have been that no one would have heard of it again if it had not been that on the 25th of March two women found a sack in some disused buildings in Church Street, Conisboro’. After inquiries, the girl was arrested, and he (Mr. Peever’s) only comment so far as the mother (Mrs. Scott) was concerned, was that she had not allowed herself to be put to much trouble.

Mrs. Scott’s Story

The first witness called was Mrs. Ada Scott, Church Street, Conisboro’, who repeated the evidence she gave at the inquest, and stated that she was the mother of 12 children. Her daughter (Mrs. Lyons) and her husband lived next-door. She spoke to Minnie about her condition about two months before Christmas, but the girl denied that anything was the matter. Witness pressed the question and asked who was the cause of it, and the girl replied, “Lyons.” The girl went on working in the house up to Thursday, February 26th. It was a great shock to witness when her daughter told her. She did nothing between February 26th and two months before Christmas. Minnie was washing all day on February 26. About 5.30 on that day Minnie called her downstairs, and witness only noticed that “she looked tired.” On the following day witness first noticed that something had happened. She did not send for a doctor. She asked her if it was a baby, but she said “no, not.” The next thing she did in, or heard of, the matter was when the police called on March 26th.

“I Let the Matter Drop.”

Cross-examined by Mr. Baddiley: She was not assured as to her daughter’s condition two months before Christmas.

You had a strong suspicion?—Witness: Yes.

You say she told you Fred Lyons was the father?—Yes.

Did you say anything to Fred Lyons?—No, sir; I did not. I told his wife.

Didn’t you consider it your duty to speak to him in the matter?—I could not say anything to him. I know it was my duty to do so.

Did you have any conversation with Lyons at any time about it?—No.

And you never make any inquiries as to whether her statement that Lyons was responsible was true?—No.

In other words, you let the matter drop entirely from that time onwards?—Yes.

Can you give us any reason why you should have allowed the matter to slide in this way?—No, sir; I can’t.

You say you had some clothes ready expecting a birth?—Yes.

So you believed in her condition to that extent?—Yes.

Did you make any clothes?—Yes, about a fortnight before.

We may take it, then, that having made certain clothes you were fairly confident that a birth would take place?—I thought it would.

Are any other persons living in the house besides Minnie?—Two sons and another daughter.

Older than the girl (Minnie)?—The boys were older and the girl younger.

And do the two boys work?—Yes; both work in the brick-yard.

Were they at work on February 26th?—Yes.

Have they regular hours?—Yes; six to 12, and one to five.

They don’t work nights?—No.

What time do they generally arrive home?—One comes home at five and the other at half-past five.

One of them was in when you came down to tea on February 26th?—Yes.

Where was the youngest girl on this afternoon?—At home.

About the house?—Yes.

Have you any idea whereabouts she would be?—Between me and Minnie.

Do you remember where she was when you came down to tea?—She was downstairs.

You were upstairs whitewashing all day, practically?—Yes.

You would come down to dinner?—Yes.

About what time was it when you went up again after dinner?—One o’clock or thereabouts.

And you went on whitewashing?—Yes, I did.

Was Minnie then washing down below?—Yes.

Was there anything suspicious about her appearance then?—No.

Did you come down between then and tea-time?—No.

There was only you, the young girl and Minnie in the house?—Yes.

When you came down, were you surprised to find the “came-tub” removed?—No.

You say you knew she had been down in the cellar? How did you know?—The things are kept down in the cellar, and she would have to go down to put the things away.

Did you notice anything unusual about her then?—No.

You suggest she was not confined on that day?—No; she was not.

When do you suggest she was?—On Friday morning.

Why do you suggest that?—Because when I came downstairs she looked so different from what she did on the Thursday.

When you went to bed on February 26th your daughter slept with you?—Yes, she did.

What time did she get up?—About five.

The usual time?—Yes.

It would be left to her to get the lads’ breakfast?—Yes.

When did you come down?—About 7.30.

How long does it take your sons to get to work?—About ten minutes.

Then they would leave for their work about 4.45?—Yes.

From that we may take it that if she was confined on Friday morning it would have to take place between a quarter to 6 and 7.30, when you came down?—Yes.

When you came down you did notice something about Minnie?—Yes; she looked so bad.

Why didn’t you consider it necessary to send for a doctor?—I didn’t think it was necessary. If she had called upon me I could have managed. I have done it for other people. I could have done for Minnie if she had only called for me.

What made you tell your daughter, Mrs. Lyons?—I thought she had a right to know.

Because of the allegations against her husband?—Yes.

You told us at the inquest that the sack the body was found in was not your property?—It was not, to my knowledge.

Do you keep fowls?—Yes.

Did you notice the feathers in the sack?—Yes.

Cross-examined by Mr. Peever: The petticoat (produced) belonged to Minnie. She went on the 12th March to a friend’s at New Edlington, and stopped there until Sergeant Lowenden sent for her.

By the Magistrates’ Clerk: Witness did not take her whitewashing materials down to the cellar that night.

Other Evidence

Annie Wale and Elizabeth Hill re-told the story of finding the body in a disused yard at Conisboro’.

Dr. James Forster (Conisboro’) also repeated the evidence he gave at the inquest, in which he expressed the opinion that the child had been born alive and had a separate existence. The child could not have lived more than three or four days.

Sergeant J. C. Lowenden (stationed at Conisboro’) spoke to visiting the disused wash-houses in Goodlad’s yard in consequence of information received from the witness Annie Wale, and finding the body in a sack. He produced the petticoat and a piece of calico found tied round the child’s neck, and stated that they were of the same material. Proceeding, he spoke to visiting a home in New Edlington and seeing Minnie Scott there, and repeated the conversation he had with the girl. He took her to Conisboro’ Police Station, and when charged she replied, “I only did it for my mother’s sake, to save trouble.”

Committed for Trial

When charged, Minnie Scott said: “I don’t wish to say anything at present, or to give evidence, or call any witnesses.”

The Chairman: Then all we have to do is to commit you for trial and send you back to the Home from where you came.

Mr. Baddiley: That is the only duty your Worships can do. I cannot oppose that.

The girl was accordingly committed, and left the court with her mother, weeping bitterly.